View previous topic :: View next topic |
Author |
Message |
slimjim Super Member
Joined: May 16, 2009 Posts: 8312 Location: Fort Worth TX
|
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2009 4:43 pm Post subject: AR-15 accuracy comparison: mil-spec handguard vs freefloat |
|
I took my S&W M&P to the range this morning and shot different ammo through it with and without the handguard to see how much of a difference in accuracy there would be. I was looking for some evidence of improvement before I chucked out the coins for a freefloat handguard. My S&W has a 16-inch barrel with 1:9 twist. When I took the handguard off to freefloat the barrel, I would feed one round at a time and rest the magizine well (without a mag inserted) on the sandbag. It made for a stable rest. I used a Leupold VXII 3-9X and fired 3-shot groups at 100 yards.
Here is the rifle.
This table shows the overall results.
Though I saw a slight improvement in accuracy with the with the barrel freefloating, it was not significant and the best groups in each configuration were comparable. Here are the best groups.
There was a slight shift in the point-of-impact with and without the handguard.
So far, I've found the results inconclusive and not supporting the expense for a freefloat handguard. However, this was my first really shooting session with the AR after an initial break-in. I think I need to go back and repeat this test with 5-shot groups and see if point-of-impact remains consistent. Give me a couple of weeks report back.
If others can share their experience with freefloat handguards that would be appreciated.
|
|
Back to top |
|
|
Donut Slayer Super Member
Joined: Jun 27, 2007 Posts: 594 Location: Pensacola, Florida
|
|
Back to top |
|
|
Pumpkinslinger Super Member
Joined: Sep 22, 2007 Posts: 5000 Location: NC foothills
|
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2009 9:06 pm Post subject: Re: AR-15 accuracy comparison: mil-spec handguard vs freefloat |
|
Good report Slimjim! Thanks.
_________________ Mike
"I ain't no better than anybody else, and there ain't nobody better than me!" Ma Kettle |
|
Back to top |
|
|
Dawgdad Super Member
Joined: Feb 08, 2006 Posts: 1065 Location: On the Prairie
|
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2009 9:31 pm Post subject: Re: AR-15 accuracy comparison: mil-spec handguard vs freeflo |
|
Not sure you will be able to compare without shelling out the bucks for the Freefloat tube. The main advantage of a free float tube is so that the sling pressure is not relayed to the barrel. If you set a factory hand guard vs a free float handguard using the magazine as the support point like you did I expect you will get the same results - inconclusive. A T-test or F-test would say they are from the same population.
If you use the handguard as the support point or even attached a bipod and then shot free float versus stock handguard you MAY see the difference in point of impact shift between the two but I would think if you were consistent form shot to shot with support position on the stock the group size would be similar. If you move around on your bag with a stock handuard the poi will shift too opening up group size.
As I said already - they main advantage comes if you are using a sling as changes in sling pressure will causes changes in POI.
_________________ Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms should be a convenience store, not a government agency... |
|
Back to top |
|
|
slimjim Super Member
Joined: May 16, 2009 Posts: 8312 Location: Fort Worth TX
|
Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 5:56 am Post subject: Re: AR-15 accuracy comparison: mil-spec handguard vs freeflo |
|
Dawgdad wrote: |
If you set a factory hand guard vs a free float handguard using the magazine as the support point" |
I should have mentioned that I supported the rifle with the handguard on the sandbag when I shot those groups. I figured that this would be similar to my hand holding the handguard. Maybe for consistency I should have shot using the magazine well as the rest point even with the handguard on.
Your point about using a sling is an important one. However, I have read where others claimed significant improvements in accuracy when using a freefloating handguard. I figure I have to shoot quite a few more rounds before I can quantify the accuracy advantage and any improvement in point-of-impact consistency. I think the advantage of a freefloated barrel is there. It will be fun doing all this shooting to find out how much! At least for now I know if I'm not using a sling, I really don't need to rush out and buy a freefloat handguard.
|
|
Back to top |
|
|
Dawgdad Super Member
Joined: Feb 08, 2006 Posts: 1065 Location: On the Prairie
|
Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 6:30 am Post subject: Re: AR-15 accuracy comparison: mil-spec handguard vs freeflo |
|
My experince has been that a good trigger shrinks groups better than a float tube if you are not using a sling.
_________________ Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms should be a convenience store, not a government agency... |
|
Back to top |
|
|
shrpshtrjoe Super Red Neck Member
Joined: Jan 26, 2005 Posts: 2965 Location: Maryland
|
|
Back to top |
|
|
slimjim Super Member
Joined: May 16, 2009 Posts: 8312 Location: Fort Worth TX
|
Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 7:54 pm Post subject: Re: AR-15 accuracy comparison: mil-spec handguard vs freeflo |
|
Dawgdad wrote: |
good trigger shrinks groups better than a float tube |
The trigger on my S&W was only 6 pounds out of the box plus smoother than most mil-spec. I did the 15 minute AR Trigger mod and reduced my trigger pull to around 4 lbs (estimate) but have not measured it. It was simple. I don't feel liking I'm having to apply excess pressure to get the round off. It even comes as a surprise which is good. This mod worked for me and I will keep this rifle like this. I'm getting ready to build an AR that is more geared for accuracy and will get a good match trigger for it, most likely a single stage JP.
|
|
Back to top |
|
|
roklok Super Member
Joined: Aug 11, 2005 Posts: 608 Location: Fairbanks, Alaska
|
Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 9:20 pm Post subject: Re: AR-15 accuracy comparison: mil-spec handguard vs freefloat |
|
Just installed a JP trigger in my Colt. Very happy with it, trigger pull went from a gritty, creepy 8 pounds to a crisp 4.5 pounds. This is with the stock hammer and hammer spring for reliability with all ammunition.
|
|
Back to top |
|
|
Dawgdad Super Member
Joined: Feb 08, 2006 Posts: 1065 Location: On the Prairie
|
Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 6:51 pm Post subject: Re: AR-15 accuracy comparison: mil-spec handguard vs freeflo |
|
slimjim wrote: |
Dawgdad wrote: |
good trigger shrinks groups better than a float tube |
The trigger on my S&W was only 6 pounds out of the box plus smoother than most mil-spec. I did the 15 minute AR Trigger mod and reduced my trigger pull to around 4 lbs (estimate) but have not measured it. It was simple. I don't feel liking I'm having to apply excess pressure to get the round off. It even comes as a surprise which is good. This mod worked for me and I will keep this rifle like this. I'm getting ready to build an AR that is more geared for accuracy and will get a good match trigger for it, most likely a single stage JP. |
When you say build - do you mean from parts or a new upper and a match lower?
If you want the best Match grade AR service rifle upper Check out White Oak Precision /White Oak Armament or Compass Lake. Most shooters at Camp Perry do.
_________________ Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms should be a convenience store, not a government agency... |
|
Back to top |
|
|
slimjim Super Member
Joined: May 16, 2009 Posts: 8312 Location: Fort Worth TX
|
Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2009 6:30 am Post subject: Re: AR-15 accuracy comparison: mil-spec handguard vs freeflo |
|
Dawgdad wrote: |
When you say build - do you mean from parts or a new upper and a match lower? |
Well I picked up my Barlett Enterprises lower receiver yesterday. So everything is possible from here. I'm not sure yet if I will build the upper from parts or buy a complete upper. I'm still investigating. Thanks for your suggested companies.
|
|
Back to top |
|
|
Dawgdad Super Member
Joined: Feb 08, 2006 Posts: 1065 Location: On the Prairie
|
Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2009 8:43 am Post subject: Re: AR-15 accuracy comparison: mil-spec handguard vs freeflo |
|
I have mulled over the idea of building an AR from parts. I may be way off base here but I always felt that the lower was more of a tab A in Slot B assembly while an upper required a littel more skill and art to get everything lined out well. Any one done a build from parts?
BTW - Slimjim -What did the Lower run you? Did it have a match trigger or a stock single stage?
_________________ Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms should be a convenience store, not a government agency... |
|
Back to top |
|
|
slimjim Super Member
Joined: May 16, 2009 Posts: 8312 Location: Fort Worth TX
|
Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2009 9:15 am Post subject: Re: AR-15 accuracy comparison: mil-spec handguard vs freeflo |
|
I purchased a stripped lower from MidwayUSA that was CNC machined by Bartlett Enterprises. They are on clearance for $99. That's basically half price. I don't expect that price to last more than a couple days.
Bartlett Enterprises Lower Receiver
|
|
Back to top |
|
|
|